
The Days of Awe in Havana and Santiago by Lurker
I
feel pretty good about this one, although in some ways it is more ambitious
than some of the others, and probably has a few more kinks to be worked out.
Takes place mostly in Synagogues, so if it ever published, it will need a glossary
at the end for Hebrew and Spanish!
You can probably catch the drift anyway!
Thank you, all of you, even the lefties! It is a privilege to participate, so
I hope I don't abuse the privilege too often!
My cousin David was a freelance photojournalist who occasionally
worked for the New York Times. His career bread and butter had always been sports
photography, mostly for the Philadelphia Inquirer, although like almost all
photographers he's always inventing sidelines, like portraits of Art Museum
Patrons, and even weddings and Bar Mitzvahs when it was absolutely necessary.
I had been going to Cuba for a while, and even though I had hardly spent a day
with this cousin in the last 15 years, the fact that I had repeatedly visited
this exotic place had spread to the farthest reaches of the family. So when
David was offered a chance to do a photo essay on 'The Jews of Cuba', he got
my number and asked me if I could be his guide. I readily agreed, maybe because
I wanted him to verify for the rest of the family that so far I wasn't in danger
of being put in any jail, or maybe because I wanted him to tell me after we
got back that such a place actually existed, and was not something that I had
imagined. Many Americans who visited Cuba in the 1990's share an obsession with
this forbidden place, not because it is forbidden , but because it is so genuinely
strange. Hopefully you have observed, dear reader, through these stories that
you have been reading, that Cuba is completely different, not only from Cleveland
and San Francisco, but also from the Dominican Republic or Brazil or every single
place in the world. If not, I will have to start these stories all over again
in order to do a better job of proving it to you. Perhaps this was my true motivation
for wanting to take my cousin to Cuba- aside from the fact that he asked me.
At the time, I knew no other Americans who had ever been there and part of the
joy of every traveler is to convince someone that the events you witnessed really
did happen.
.
My qualifications as guide were that I pretty much knew
how to operate in this parallel universe, and I also knew my way around the
Jewish Prayer Book. David thought it might be helpful if someone could tell
him when to bow and when to take three steps forward, since he had forgotten
a few of the basics in the 30 years since his Bar Mitzvah. Although actually,
maybe he just told me that he needed my help in the synagogue in order to enlist
me. Generally speaking, photographers are not afraid of protocol, since their
job is to stick their nose into everybody's business and act like they are supposed
to be there.
David drove up from Philly in his battered Chevrolet to meet me in Vermont,
which is on the way to Montreal and Havana. He explained to me and my Cuban
wife Dalia, who was staying behind in Vermont, that the New York Times hadn't
actually promised to run this particular piece, but the Jews of Cuba were hot,
ever since this particular tribe had been rediscovered. We would go down for
Yom Kippur, for maximum dramatic effect. True, a photo of a Cuban Jew walking
the streets of Havana had a certain value at any time of the year, but a communist
Jew davvenning during the high holy days, or an anti communist Jew sitting in
a Succah and protesting the lack of religious freedom, or maybe both Jews, however
the story turned out to be, would be exponentially more compelling. Maybe it
would be the break David needed to get away from sports and portraits into the
more prestigious world of international feature stories. Dalia didn't really
understand why the world would really care about the Jews of Cuba, or for that
matter, why should they care about the 11 million Cubans of Cuba who according
to her hadn't done a thing for themselves since the time of Antonio Maceo. "Cojones"
she would shout out. "Los Cubanos no merecen nada hasta que rebeldan del
Singao!" She was already well on her way to citizenship, because she thought
like a Republican, even though she was still thinking in Spanish.
Since the airplane left Montreal close to dawn, and since
Montreal is about three hours away from where I live, we drove up the night
before and then stayed awake for the rest of the night getting re-acquainted.
He told me about his wealthy Jewish in laws, who were either real estate developers
or lawyers. We were definitely the poor sheep of the family, perhaps because
we are so easily distracted from the pursuit of money by just about anything.
I tried to explain everything to him in advance, knowing that this was impossible.
In Cuba, especially in out of the way places, we might be the wealthiest people
that the person we were talking to had ever met. All foreigners, even if they
are on food stamps in a rent-controlled apartment, have lives that are about
as incomprehensible to the average Cuban as the life of the Shah of Iran would
be to the average American.
About the only thing that I had really known about my
cousin is that his first child had been born with a severe learning disability.
The fulcrum of the life of David and his wife Amy had been to teach their son
Marc how to eat with a fork, and sit in a classroom, and take his medicine without
throwing a temper tantrum, and preparing him as much as possible for the time
when they wouldn't be around to do this any more. They had a younger son whom
they certainly hoped would follow in the footsteps of the lawyers and real estate
developers, so he could earn enough money to take care of his brother forever.
Amy was just a social worker trying to help the disadvantaged, but the main
value of her job was that it provided health insurance for Marc.
We flew to Havana, bleary eyed, and since I am a cheapskate,
I told the taxi driver to take us to the Lido hotel in La Habana Vieja. I learned
a long time ago that underachievers can have pretty much the same quality of
life as real estate developers, provided that they are willing to sleep in lousy
hotels. You can sit in the lobbies of the most expensive hotels all day long,
and all you have to do is be willing to be in the cheapest hotel when you are
unconscious and don't know where you are. This simple trick is almost enough
to save anyone from having to work for idiot bosses, unless you happen to have
something like a learning disabled child, in which case the idiot bosses are
much harder to avoid.
David had a week to spare, and since Rosh Hashanah and
Yom Kippur are always 10 days apart, I had decided that we should fly down after
Rosh Hashanah in order to be able to stay for Succot. My reasoning was that
a picture of a Jew in the Synagogue at Rosh Hashanah would be pretty much the
same picture as the Jew in the Synagogue at Yom Kippur, since it is difficult
to tell from a photo whether someone has been eating in the past few hours.
Succot, however, offered other potential possibilities of Jews sitting in flimsy,
impermanent structures, by which I mean the booths that are built to be flimsy,
and not the concrete buildings that everyone lives in that are impermanent for
lack of maintenance. The plan was to visit all three Jewish Synagogues in Havana
in the days before Rosh Hashanah, which included one Shabbat, and then go to
Santiago for Yom Kippur. Then we would come back to Havana in time to see the
Succah being prepared.. David had about 200 rolls of film donated by Kodak.
They were also hoping for the one photo of the really memorable Cuban Jew, with
the New York Times article noting, as if carelessly, that the film was Kodak
ektapress 2600. Everything was dependent upon us finding that one Jew.
II
We started our reconnaisance work at the Main Synagogue
in Havana, the Patronato, which is led by Dr. Jacob Springer. Dr Springer is
not a Rabbi, and in fact there are no Rabbis who live in Cuba. He is, however,
a good Communist, which is more than enough qualification to lead the Jewish
Community on the island.
We walked into the Synagogue's library and met Naomi Behar,
who is the librarian and the unofficial leader of the Synagogue. Most every
Synagogue has somebody who in charge, and somebody else who organizes all of
the work.
I introduced myself- "My name is Michael, this is
my cousin David and we're here from the United States to do a photo piece on
the Jews of Cuba"
Naomi was busy with something so she said, "You'll
have to speak to Dr. Springer" Although I got the feeling that even if
she wasn't busy, foreign photographers were automatically the business of Dr.
Springer. Only problem was that Dr. Springer was also busy. We walked over to
his office and stood outside the closed door with the glass window watching
him talk to somebody on the phone. We came back every few minutes, and we could
tell that he had seen us, but we obviously weren't important enough to be greeted,
even after he got off the phone and stood writing at his desk. Of course, the
whole world has changed since Abraham first installed a door on each of he four
sides of his tent, just so that a guest could be welcomed as quickly as possible.
David had spent his entire working life inviting himself
into places where he wasn't really wanted, which is a specialized skill. The
principal trade secret is to make a joke of everything, be exceptionally good-natured,
never get offended, act like you are everyone's best friend, and despite themselves,
most people come to believe that you actually are a long lost friend, and then
you are permitted to do whatever it is that you want to do.
So David knocked at the door while Dr. Springer was writing
at the desk.
"Come back later," said Dr. Springer.
"When should we come back?" asked David, I didn't need to translate
because Dr Springer speaks English.
"What is it that you want," said Dr. Springer, a little bit annoyed.
From past experience I have learned that the Jews of Cuba are Cubans in every
sense, which means hospitable, garrulous, willing to stay up most of the night
just to welcome any stranger with or without a bottle of rum, just for the chance
to talk about the world. However, it now seemed that leaders of the Jewish Community
were also Machers in the traditional sense, which means self important, imperious,
irritable.
"I'm from the New York Times," said David, walking into the room covered
with cameras, and extending his hand in friendship, while neglecting to mention
that he was working on spec. "I've been sent here to take some pictures
during the Holidays. We'd like to make your community here a little more famous!"
And he smiled, almost winking, as if fame was just a detail that he could pretty
easily arrange if he decided that he wanted to.
"You'll have to come back later," said Dr. Springer. Fame apparently
meant little to him, since he was already the most important and therefore the
most famous Jew on the island.
"When should we come back" I asked. And David added, "You know,
after we get this story out, the Jews of America will want to do a lot more
to help the Jewish Community here". David was sincere in this offer. He
knew that the Jews of America are a generous people, and part of their religious
belief is to help their benighted brethren in the four corners of the world.
He also knew how to talk to Machers, maybe from his experience working the Art
Museums.
Dr. Springer looked at David, and then said, in Spanish,
"You're working for the New York Times?"
"You've heard of it?" smiled David, and he showed him his press pass.
The pass, however, was just from the Philadelphia Inquirer. Dr. Springer knew
the difference.
"My regular job is with the Inquirer. But I've done lots of pieces for
the Times" Then he took out his portfolio, showing a few pieces from the
Times with his byline.
"What kind of visa did you come to Cuba with," asked Springer
"He came on a general license from the US " I explained. And his visa
is a regular tourist visa. It's just a lot easier that way".
"Journalists are required to notify the Cuban authorities that they are
visiting Cuba for professional reasons. We want to make sure that professional
journalists are extended every courtesy, and are given all the assistance they
might need"
This is where my knowledge of how to accomplish things
in Cuba began to be useful.
"It's true that he works for the New York Times, as you can see" I
explained. But he's also a tourist. He's with me, his cousin. My wife is Cuban,
from Santiago. We're going there to visit my family, and we're also going to
Varadero before we go back home. We explained all of this at the Customs. We
came through the next to the last booth, and there was a mulata working there
who after hearing our plans told us that the tourist visa would be sufficient,
since that was one of the reasons for our trip. I didn't ask her name, but I
could point her out to you at the airport"
I've never really learned if the Cuban authority figures believe all the stories
I invent, but the most important thing is always to have a plausible story.
This concept of 'plausible assertability', a close cousin of 'plausible deniability'
seems to stop the authorities dead in the fulfillment of their official duties.
"When do they plan to run the story," asked Dr. Springer.
" Right after the Holidays" And then, I added, "you know, pictures
from the Days of Awe wouldn't be very useful around Passover"
"Come back tomorrow morning" said Dr. Springer. "I can pose for
you tomorrow. The light is better in the morning. One picture at the top of
the steps outside, and then another picture with me working here in my office.
You can take some other pictures if you want to".
On the way out the door I lingered a little at a photo
on the wall. I made sure that David saw what I was looking at, and that he had
a chance to look as well.
"Wow" he said, after we were alone in the hallway away from Dr Springer's
office. "Jacob Springer and Fidel. I guess this guy's got connections"
'That's his boss" I explained.
"What was all that talk about customs, and visas? I didn't get any of that"
"You're supposed to tell the Cubans when you come through that you're a
journalist. Tourists can do anything they want. A tourist can sleep with a goat,
if he's discrete about it, but journalists are important. Don't worry, he'll
probably tell the proper people all that they need to know about you."
I might have been exaggerating about the goat, because I don't really know if
a tourist could sleep with a goat. I only imagine that it could be arranged.
Although to be fair, it could probably be arranged almost as easily in New Jersey,
provided that a goat could be procured.
"What a pompous jerk that guy is," said David, who didn't bother to
mince words, since all of his thoughtfulness goes into creating images.
"He's the head of the Jewish Community" I explained
"So? Isn't it possible that the head of the Jewish Community could be a
regular fellow?"
"You know how it was in the old Soviet Union?" I asked. ."The
head of the Orthodox Church was appointed by Stalin. If he wasn't a friend of
Stalin's, he wouldn't be allowed to be the head of the Orthodox Church. That's
pretty much how I imagine it works here with all the Churches. You know, all
the Churches here collect donations from the world. They keep some, and they
give some over to the government. I don't really know this is true, I just imagine
that it might be true. My guess is that some years ago El Commandante thought
to himself, 'Who can I appoint to be the tax collector from the Jews of the
world? Maybe he had to think about it for a few days, carefully weighing everyone's
loyalty in his omniscient mind. Although most of the Jews were small businessmen
and left right after the revolution, there were plenty of Communist Jews who
were loyal to the Revolution. You know how we are- we're in bed with the international
bankers, and then we go out to have breakfast with our buddy Trotsky. That's
why the world loves us so much."
In fairness, I have to say that maybe everything I said about Dr Springer and
Fidel is a form of Lashon Hara, Hebrew for Evil Tongue, which is a terrible
sin. Perhaps Dr. Springer became head of the Jewish Community because of his
profound studies of Kabbalah, or quite possibly through his knowledge of Mussar
literature. I'm sure it is very wrong of me to speculate about things that I
know nothing about. I therefore made a mental note to repent for slandering
Dr.Springer, my fellow Jew, and during the Days of Awe! . Slander is a very
serious business, and every Jew should be given the benefit of the doubt. .
We went back to the library to speak to Naomi, who was friendly enough to give
us all the contacts we needed in Havana. She set up a meeting with the representative
from the Joint Distribution Committee, which has been quietly funding the approximately
1,000 stubborn tropical Jews who never left for Miami or Tel Aviv. Friday night
synagogue services became much better attended after the Joint became involved,
perhaps because of the young community organizers sent from Argentina who organized
Israeli dancing, Hebrew lessons, camping trips for the children, and also perhaps
because the oneg shabbat usually included a chicken leg and other foods that
were not generally available. In no way do I mean to imply any cynicism here,
because the Sabbath is meant to be celebrated and not endured, and food goes
a long way to make people feel better.
Naomi also made the arrangements for us to visit Jews
who originally came from Morocco, and other Jews who originally came from Poland.
But even before we could go to keep these appointments, we made our own arrangements
with a few of the Jews who are always on the lookout for Jewish tourists. These
are a subclass of jineteros that the guidebooks seldom talk about. The cigar
and chica selling jineteros hang around outside the Casa de la Trova looking
for tourists in general, because that's where the cigar and chica buying tourists
are likely to be found. The Jewish jineteros hang around outside the synagogue,
for the same reason, looking for Jewish tourists to whom they can tell stories
about the Jewish community, and maybe allow pictures of themselves, while mentioning
how terrible the situation really is for everyone. It would be misleading to
classify these generally older gentlemen as schnorrers, because schnorrers usually
ask for money for nothing, whereas jineteros generally try to provide some service.
The only service that these older Jews can offer is their memories, but fortunately,
memory has always been a valuable commodity in the Jewish world. We are generally
happy to pay for personal recollections of where someone's father's clothing
business used to be located, and exactly why the Board of Directors of one Synagogue
split over some ritual or social or personal issue, forcing half the community
to angrily create a new Synagogue across town or around the corner.
We went to the house of Luis, one of these elderly Jews,
who it turned out had been a composer and a historian. He had a few CD's made
of one of his symphanies, which he was happy to give us. Of course we gave him
some money, after eating lunch that his sister served for us on the balcony
of his older building in Central Havana. While we ate, we were serenaded by
a few caged parakeets that lived on the balcony where they could observe the
motorcycles and the bicycle taxis and the tourists with their Cuban girlfriends.
Luis' sister explained that these were older parakeets, and perhaps like older
Jews, they were not so much observing what was going on but comparing what they
were now seeing with the way things used to be. Nobody really knows whether
older parakeets are talking about the things that are happening to them then
and there, or the things that happened when the world was younger and their
future was still ahead of them. It is even possible that parakeets, unlike older
men, prefer to speculate on the times yet to come.
Luis accepted our twenty dollars, with a wry smile of
chagrin, which was able to convey both his gentle gratitude, and his recognition
of the absurdities with which life eventually confronts us all. His particular
absurdity, apparently, was to grow very old in his Havana apartment, a witness
to forty years of revolutionary struggle. At least the synagogues were now open
again, and he had the opportunity to meet and confer with Jews from all around
the world, just as older Jews used to do in coffee houses in Vienna, or hummus
eateries in Tunisia. If he had gone to Miami, the universe would certainly have
arranged a different absurdity for him, perhaps even stranger than the one he
was living. We talked about all of this, with David shooting a few rolls of
film, and then Luis went to the back room and brought out an actual bottle of
schnapps that had been brought over by a tourist from Toronto. We drank, to
life, of course, and to music, and to the parakeets.
Luis then took us on a small tour of the Jewish world,
in a taxi that we hired. We visited the old Jewish commercial area in the old
city on O'Reilly and Obispo, the old kosher butcher shop that was closed down
before the new kosher butcher was closed down, the old vacant Orthodox Synagogue
back when Havana had two Orthodox Synagogues and virtually no truly Orthodox
Jews. Something about the Cuban atmosphere- the tropical birdsong, or the beautiful
beaches, or the enticing chicas, or the rum, or the lack of anti-semitism, or
the gracious and courteous live and let live environment, whatever it was, fundamentalism
surrendered without much resistance, and has never really returned to this day.
Even the pastors at the most evangelical churches might have one or two girlfriends
on the side, and although the flock would consider this to be incorrect, who
would want to throw the first stone?
When this first tour was over we dropped Luis off back
at his house and went to visit the Sephardic Synagogue not too far away from
the Patronato. We were fortunate that the President of this Synagogue was in
his study, and he .
Immediately rose to welcome us and give us a tour of the
building. Like all the other Synagogues of Cuba, this Synagogue was rescued
from its prior use as a public building and converted back into a Synagogue
when religion became approved again sometime after the fall of the Soviet Union.
The President of this Synagogue let it be known that he was President by virtue
of being elected, not appointed. We took many photos of the building and the
people who were walking in and out and interviewed the Synagogue President for
a long time. Then we went to visit the Jews from Poland and the Jews from Morocco
and ate special cakes and took many photos of the children and talked about
the Jewish world, just like we would have done in Vermont or anywhere else.
Then we went back to the Lido hotel.
But David was no where near ready to sleep, even though
we had already accomplished a lot. Just as I had warned him, the real story
was not the Jews of Cuba, but the Cubans of Cuba, of whom the Jews were just
the tiniest subset. We walked around the old city, and shot another 20 rolls
of film with our flash apparatus , photos of old cars and black and white kids
playing stickball and the gorgeous buildings that like certain women retained
almost all of their beauty even though they had been much younger and fresher
so long ago. Like so many other people, David was astonished at the number of
unique images that he had never seen before- images that are available for our
viewing pleasure at every single moment. Some people were arguing, and some
people were dancing and some people were surrounded by other people who were
gesticulating and some people were standing outside a building shouting 'OYE!
MARILU! TELEFONOOOOO!!! This was all new to David because he had never been
outside of the United States before and now he was in Havana with all the people
on bicycles and the people selling blenderized fruit drinks from the window
of their house and the harbor and the ocean waves and the fort on the other
side of the bay in the background. It is quite enough to drive many of us crazy
Two young girls were riding in a 50's era Chrysler as
we were approaching the statues of the lions at the entrance to the Prado and
when they saw the two us the taxi stopped and they asked us if we wanted to
accompany them somewhere. David smiled, feeling the pure joy of the moment,
and then starting taking more pictures. He didn't want to go anywhere with these
girls, because his wife and two children were waiting for him in Philadelphia,
and he knew beyond any doubt that his wife Amy was the best thing that had ever
happened to him and the most important thing in his life. But he did want to
take these pictures, and the girls gladly posed for him, in and out of the Chrysler,
laughing, and teasing him a little for being so faithful, and appreciating the
fact that he was in love and that love is that which most deserves to be honored.
I was also in love with my Cuban wife, and if this was not enough all by itself
to keep me eternally faithful, (and I am stating this hypothetically, without
really knowing one way or the other), I was moved by David's loyalty, and the
knowledge that he might snitch on me, to emulate his devotion, for the entire
week that we were in Cuba.
We went back to the hotel, eventually, and walked up the
stairs since the elevator wasn't working, all the way to the rooftop bar where
food was still being served even though the posted hour was long past. We sat
at one of the tables and looked out at the beautiful city, more interesting
than Rome, perhaps because it captured the entire history of modern Rome transforming
itself into ancient Rome, as buildings fell in very slow motion before our eyes.
True, it might take a few decades of time lapse photography, because even fallen
building are astonishingly rebellious against their final collapse. But we could
feel that the moment was approaching, when the ornate pillars of those buildings
that were missing only a few bricks or lintels would surrender to the inevitable,
with a sigh and then a loud cry, and hunch down suddenly, and a cloud of white
dust would then envelop the surrounding streets, moving visibly towards the
surprised pedestrians before blinding them, and leaving a few walls and arches
when the dust finally settled many minutes later, that themselves might continue
to stand for another decade. It was all apparent, and known in advance, because
the human eye is capable of seeing even more than the camera, since it can look
into the future.
And at the same time a few selected parts of ancient Rome
were being renovated and transformed back into modern Rome, as scaffolding might
be put up to protect entirely empty facades here and there, the walls and columns
that had already undergone the first stages of collapse, only to be resuscitated
by hundreds of emergency artisans, and thousands of pounds of cement mixed with
shovels scraping on the closed off streets, day after day, and carried up by
ropes and buckets, with thin negro workers as assiduous as the builders of the
tower of Babel, year after year, until all the stone carvers had finished their
work and paint was obtained from somewhere and lo! The glory of ancient Rome
was made new again! Living in Havana is almost like living in various centuries
at the same time, as the magnificent opulence created by slaves and sugar and
trade and pillage and the ruins of this wealth exist simultaneously, like a
corpse that the doctors have learned to keep alive forever. The ruins of the
city serve only to make it more eternal
. Our first day in Cuba and David had already shot forty
roles of film. We slept at last, only because sleep is necessary, even to children
who want to stay awake and see more forever!
III
In the morning we were back on the job very early. First,
we went to see the Argentine representative from the charitable Jewish world,
the Joint Distribution Committee, that had been buying so much chicken.
"What's with this Dr Springer" David wanted to know
"Ahh, Doctor Springer" answered the young shaliach, which is Hebrew
for the guy who is sent to educate the community and maybe also distribute the
goodies. "What can I say about Dr Springer?"
"What a control freak"
"Ahh, Dr Springer" said the Argentine
We talked about all the good work that the Jews of the
world were doing for the approximately 1,000 Jews of Cuba, shrinking all the
time as Jews were quietly permitted to go away to Israel, although not shrinking
as quickly as they would have if not, as I mentioned before, for the chicken,
and also of course the religious renaissance that was apparent all over the
island, even amongst the practitioners of Yoruba.
Then we went back to the Patronato for our morning appointment with Springer.
He was waiting for us in his office, and he addressed us by saying, "New
York Times".
'That's right" said David.
'OK. I'm ready now. First, we go outside the building. I want you to take a
picture of me holding the Torah on the top step of the entranceway".
"We don't need that picture" said David. "You know, the pictures
that I take are more informal. That's what people like. Just everyday people
going about their everyday business".
"Maybe you don't know this" said Dr Springer, "but all the Synagogues
in Havana are part of a Coordinating Committee, of which I have been the chairperson
for more than fifteen years. There must be a reason I'm the chairperson, don't
you think? So let's take the pictures that I suggest, and if you want you can
take all kinds of other pictures, and use whatever you want. But you'll see
that I generally know what I'm talking about."
I was all for doing whatever Dr Springer wanted, because
he was right, he couldn't force us to use any particular picture once we got
back to New York- his authority didn't extend quite that far. But David has
a rebellious streak in him, which is why he became a photographer and not a
Macher.
'That's O.K" he said. "I don't want that picture. No posed pictures.
If you want I can take a few pictures of you right now, just talking to us"
"OK, we can go into my office and you can take a picture of me there".
'You know what?" said David. "If you don't want me to take any pictures
of you, we don't have to. I already found another Jewish President", referring
to the Sephardic Synagogue. "In New York they probably don't know the difference.
One Jewish President is as good as another!"
Dr Springer made a mental note to himself, and then just
said, "I'm a very busy man. I'm responsible for all the Jews of Cuba. If
you don't want my help, I have a lot of other things to do" And just as
he said this, David took the lens of the camera that he had already focused
and snapped Dr Springer's picture.
"That's the picture I wanted" he smiled. Just you going about your
business. I know you're very busy, and I want to thank you for all your time"
And then he smiled his affable country club smile, like he had known Springer
for years, and was also a good friend of his wife and family too, if he happened
to have one. "We'll come to Shabbat services tomorrrow night, but I won't
take any pictures, because it's Shabbat," he added, under my tutelage,
"But maybe I'll snap a few shots before Shabbat begins. Thank you for all
your advice" and he smiled again, and then took another picture of the
Dr Springer who was trying to show that none of this startled him.
"Oh, I almost forgot" said David. The guy from the Joint told me that
you had a really good pharmacy here- maybe the best in the whole country. I
want to go over there and snap a few pictures"
We walked down the hall, leaving Dr Springer behind. "That was impressive"
I said, and I have to admit, that although I am not as rebellious as David,
I was laughing. "Where did you learn to talk to people like that?"
"The only way to deal with pushy people is to be more pushy than they are.
The hell with this guy Springer! I don't want any pictures of him carrying a
Torah like he was about to cross the Red Sea. They'd laugh me out of New York
if I showed up with those kinds of pictures."
We spent much of the day on the job, first at the pharmacy,
then over to the Jewish cemetery. then back to the Patronato to shoot the Israeli
folk dancing led by the wife of the Argentinian. In the evening we went over
to Orthodox Synagogue in the old City for the regular evening service. We got
there early, so I could ask a few questions about proper decorum- would anybody
mind if we took pictures during the service? We were surprised to learn that
there was a Lubavitch Rabbi who was visiting for the Holidays from New Orleans,
which is another place that you don't associate with Lubavitch, although of
course they are everywhere, even Havana, at least during the Days of Awe. The
Rabbi shrugged, just like all of his antecedents before him, and said, "It's
not shabbas, nu? Take all the pictures you want! It won't hurt anybody! It might
even help!" So throughout the service, David was working the room, both
the men's section and the women's section, crouching up to the Bimah to get
a close up when the Ark was opened during Alenu, looking back at the sixty or
so gathered people and capturing the faces of each of them, snapping the Rabbi
a few times during his drash. It didn't bother anyone, because he had remembered
my advice and didn't take any pictures during the Amidah but actually took off
his cameras, stood by my side, bowed when I bowed, and followed along until
the Amidah was finished, when he went back to work.
We stayed around after the service to talk to everyone
and take more pictures. Everyone was friendly, but really not all that interested.
"Lots of Jews come here" said an old man with a Chinese sounding name
that I can't quite remember. The Jews of the world come here like we were some
sort of zoo animals. Two TV crews already, one from Europe. Magazines every
few months, we've seen it all. Not the New York Times, though. Who knows, maybe
something will come of it all"
It didn't bother David that this guy felt like a zoo animal,
because if his assignment was to go to the zoo, his job was to come back with
zoo pictures that nobody had ever seen before. But it did bother him that TV
crews had already covered this story.
The Rabbi was trying to make conversation with a young
black man who believed he had a Jewish Grandmother and wanted to find out what
that might mean. The Rabbi didn't speak Spanish, and the Cuban black guy didn't
speak English and certainly not Yiddish or Arabic- the Rabbi was originally
from Morocco. . I was able to translate the most important question, which was
to determine that the grandmother was the mother of his mother and not the mother
of his father, but then they found a language in common- Russian! Seems that
the black guy had been a medical technician who had even been to Moscow. Maybe's
he's in Jerusalem by now, or leading Synagogue services on some small college
campus, wherever they sent him.
Before we went home, the Rabbi asked us if we were coming
back to Davven Shacharit, and since he was inviting, we did the whole thing
all over again in the morning. By now David had 80 rolls in the can and was
beginning to feel that he was going to accomplish something.
And that's how it went for the next few days, until we
caught our plane to Santiago on the morning before Yom Kippur. We went back
to the Sephardic Synagogue for Shabbat, and back to Luis' house a few times,
and back to the Orthodox Shul, and over to the place where the chickens were
sometimes slaughtered according to, if not the most stringent supervision, at
least by someone who had learned from someone the right way to slaughter a chicken.
And we had plenty of time to take pictures of everyday life in Cuba. As always
happens we met many incredible people. One of the doormen of the hotel Lido
had an uncle who used to be one of Fidel's official photographers. This doorman
was also a wedding photographer, so the three of us went over to the uncle's
where I wanted to talk about Fidel. The former official photographer described
him as being pretty much like Dr Springer, not really appreciative of anything
that went on around him.
"Raoul, on the other hand, was always a good man," said the uncle.
I don't care what people say. He treated us all like human beings. Always friendly,
knew everybody's name. Not at all like his brother". And even though I
am crazy about Cuba, and would have loved to have heard more, these other three
were crazy about photography, and stayed up for hours talking about solutions,
and what to use if the right kind of silver wasn't available, and how to create
your own emulsifier out of household chemicals. They left good friends, and
promised to share their work in the future, in order to try to bring the art
of photogarphy to an even higher level.
IV
Santiago was the Jewish community that I knew pretty well.
I am at least an honorary member of the shul, and I may even be a voting member,
because I think I once gave them a donation which might cover synagogue dues
for the next several years. Not that I am such a big donor, but the dues are
very small, since they are payable in Cuban pesos. They have even given me a
nickname there, because over the years I have taught them a few melodies for
the closing hymn 'Adon Olam. They call me, 'Miguel Adon Olam', which is strictly
speaking, a variety of blasphemy, because it means 'Miguel, Master of the World'.
This is a direct refutation of Maimonides' 13 principles of faith, and even
a slap at the Shema, which proclaims that there is only one Master of the Universe.
Actually, though, it is more likely that this nickname is without theological
significance, and results only from the fact that I have a Teutonic surname,
and no Latino is ever very good at pronouncing German names. There are linguists
who claim that German and Spanish are both very beautiful languages, although
there seems to be some kind of unresolved contradiction in this assertion. Well,
I suppose it is possible to appreciate the birdsong of the crows as well as
the nightingales.
Years before, when I went to Santiago the very first time,
while I was staying at the home of the pimiento widow in Vista Allegre, I naturally
had asked the people I would meet if there was any such thing as a Jewish Synagogue
in Santiago de Cuba. Cubans on the street are very polite, and they prefer to
not disappoint anyone who is asking for information. One person became very
excited when I told him that I was looking for Jews, because he knew a Jewish
family and would be happy to lead me on such an important mission. We walked
to an outlying area of the city, and when we got to the house it turned out
that the family was from Lebanon. It was a close call, and that encouraged me.
Others told me that there was an entire community of Jews living in a place
called el Cobre 15 miles out of town. This made me suspicious because Jews usually
live at the center of things and would probably not be out living in the mountains
somewhere. Another time I asked a woman working in the tourist offices if she
knew of any Jews, and she assured me that she herself was Jewish! We talked
about the religion a little, and she didn't seem to know very much about it,
and then it turned out that by "Jewish' she meant that she had never been
baptized. All of the unbaptized people are called 'Judios'. I even saw a few
young girls walking around town with star of David necklace. At first I would
accost them and ask if they were Jewish, but these girls didn't know what I
was talking about, and so I learned that they wore this particular six pointed
jewelry because they liked it and not for any other reason. I even found somebody
who was walking around with a coca cola tee shirt with the words 'coca kola'
written in Hebrew, but this shirt had been given to him by a friend from Canada.
For the life of me, I couldn't find any evidence of a single Jew anywhere in
the city, although I asked around pretty regularly. I had to go to all the way
to Havana where the Jews there gave me the address of the Synagogue in Santiago.
Actually it was Naomi at the Patronato, always helpful, who had given me this
address. Perhaps Dr Springer would have given it to me as well, after a satisfactory
interview.
David and I now had a long friendly interview with my
friend the President of the Santiago Synagogue, and her two children, the eldest
of whom was now pregnant. A few years before I had been appointed judge of the
Queen Esther competition during Purim, and I had voted for this daughter, a
little bit before she celebrated her Quince. . To be honest, the judging was
fixed, because I had been given some suggestions as to who should be elected
, since I was an outsider who might not know the fairest way to confer these
honors. There were less than ten young girls in the Synagogue, so everyone was
Queen Esther at least once, when her turn came around. Perhaps, however, I could
have selected a different girl. Since the power had truly been vested in me,
that other Queen Esther would then have served for the entire year, and the
President's daughter would have had no recourse except to sulk a little at the
ubiquity of capricious injustice. That's the way the world is-Young Queen Esther
one year, pregnant with a first child just a little bit later.
We visited all of my friends, starting with Jose Almeida,
the schoolteacher who had taught himself enough of the prayer book to lead the
services, and Adela Brynszteyn, the woman doctor, born in Hungary, who was just
about to take off for Israel when the paperwork came through. Her name indicates
that she was probably a distant cousin of Trotsky, who was born Bronstein. Adela
was a little bit Trotsky like, in that she at first appeared to be loyal to
the system, while objecting to certain parts of it. Adela lived in Vista Alegre
with her old mother near the Hotel Santiago where I used to live when I first
came to Santiago, and she had a car that had been awarded to her for International
medical service someplace in Africa. Before I knew better, I used to ask her
if she could give me a ride from her house to the Synagogue and back. She had
to explain that this was impossible, since the government might think that she
was an illegal taxi driver taking a tourist someplace for money. It seemed a
little unreasonable to me that two members of the same Church couldn't ride
in the same car on Shabbat , since I don't think the intention of the State
was to enforce a variation on the Rabbinic prohibition against driving on Shabbat
in general . But this doctor had been involved in the emigration process for
years and didn't want to take any chances.
Of the approximately one hundred Jews that had lived in
Santiago when I first started going there, about twenty five had already moved
to Israel. This was part of the quiet negotiations that had taken place between
Israel and Cuba. I'm not sure exactly what as in it for Cuba, except maybe Fidel
had been paying attention when all the Jewish troublemakers had started such
a clamor back in the Soviet Union. Jews are always joking about everything,
even when they are making trouble, and perhaps Fidel didn't want these few Cuban
Jews to start inventing Jewish Fidel jokes that might spread first to the Lebanese
Cubans, and then to the Chinese Cubans, and who knows where it could end?
The Jewish medical community was leaving faster than anyone
else. In addition to this Hungarian Cuban Doctor, a pharmacist, and a nurse,
and another doctor, and a medical technician had also left the country, along
with their entire families. Amazingly, the Jews kept graduating new doctors
almost as fast as the old doctors were leaving. This was also the case of Synagogue
service leaders. Just as soon as a young man or woman learned how to lead the
Friday night or Saturday morning service- off they went to Israel. I would like
to be able to say that these young Zionist Jews were inspired by their new-found
love of the Hebrew language, and wanted to live in a place where they could
speak Hebrew or at least Yiddish every day. I think, however, that there may
have been other reasons. Actually, the Spanish word "Ay" is a very
close cognate of the Yiddish word "Oy", and this could be the basis
for the affinity that these young Cuban Jews had for the Semitic languages,
since both these words are used so often. 'Ay,ay,ay!' has almost the same meaning
as '"Oy, oy oy!".
Incidentally, it is vile propaganda that Cuban medical
professionals are not allowed to leave the country without compensating the
Cuban Government for the free medical education that the revolution gladly provides.
The Miami Mafia likes to spread all sorts of malicious anti-Cuba stories. Yes,
it is true that when Adela went for one of her interviews, the subject of her
free medical education was raised by the Cuban authorities. Adela was almost
sixty years old, so she simply noted that she had been serving the people of
Cuba as a doctor for more than thirty years, and had also gone off to Africa
almost when the Cubans began their foreign policy of doctor diplomacy. In her
opinion, therefore, she had pretty much paid for the free medical education
that had been provided. The Cuban authorities were convinced by the reasonableness
of this argument, and never again asked for reimbursement, perhaps because Adela
had done her part for the Federation of Women and the Comittee for the Defense
of the Revolution. .
Naturally Adela had to leave her car and house behind so they could be turned over to other people who also wanted to contribute to the development of society. These are the rules, and every nation strives to live by the rule of law, and not the rule of man. The biggest problem with the anti-Cubans in Miami is that they are always exaggerating, like claiming that doctors always have to compensate the State for their education. Maybe this is sometimes true, but I am here as a witness that it is an indignity to claim that it is always true.
Adela would be permitted to leave the country with fifty
pounds of personal possessions, which is almost a full pound for every year
that she had been alive. I suppose that there are many people like Adela who
have in the course of their lives collected various knickknacks that might weigh
more than fifty pounds all together. Actually, most of the things that we seem
to want to carry from place to place are superfluous, as the people who have
hired moving vans have often learned to their chagrin. Why schlep everything
from here to there when we can just as easily buy new things where we are going?
But many of us, like Adela, are incorrigible pack rats, and it was difficult
for Adela to decide whether she should take letters from her childhood, or a
few nice dresses, or perhaps medical manuscripts that she had written. I want
to confess here, since I am writing this story as we are approaching yet another
Yom Kippur, that I helped Adela break one of these minor Cuban statutes. I agreed
to take all of her dresses with me out of the country, and mail them to her
later, so she could take her manuscripts, which was really not necessary, since
dresses can be purchased almost everywhere in Israel. I am not sure why people
have so many sentimental attachments, but it is just another human weakness
for which we should probably repent. I consider the fact that I essentially
smuggled these dresses out of the country to be a minor sin, like wearing a
shirt that is a mixture of wool and linen. Although I am also cognizant of the
point of view that it is beyond our ability to weigh the sins against God in
their proper proportion, which is why eating lobster may very well be as serious
as slander against Dr Springer. By extension metaphysically, it may also be
true that breaking a small ordinance and statute of the State, such as smuggling
out dresses, may be every bit as serious as buying and selling tomatoes, or
hiring your neighbor to do some masonry work, or even inventing a Jewish Fidel
joke. Both the Heavens and the State may have a perspective that ordinary people
are incapable of understanding.
David and I visited many other people, such as the Synagogue
President's sister, who was ashamed to invite us into her kitchen because the
paint was peeling and the building was dingy in general. This made the picture
much more desirable to David, because perhaps this photo of the Jewish woman
in her best dress holding a dirty rag in the dingy kitchen might be exactly
what the New York Times wanted. He took an entire roll of film of this embarrassed
woman in her kitchen, hoping for the best.
In Santiago de Cuba, we were of course staying at my wife's sister's house near
the junction of Trocha and the road that goes off to the Spanish fort protecting
the harbor. Efigenia, whom everyone called Fifi, had left her husband Fidencio
soon after he sold the family refrigerator so he could spend money on one of
his girlfriends. It seems that many of the Cubans in Cuba can't stick to the
normal conventions of respectable society, like going out with your girlfriends
in the middle of the day, returning home every evening, and spending your own
money for beer, or dresses. Just like the Cubans in Miami, they seem to have
a compulsion to cross the lines of honesty by their exaggerated behavior. Fifi
was now living with her14 year old son Erlin, and her communist sister's 13
year old negra daughter Yulia, and whoever happened to be visiting. There were
two bedrooms in the house, so there was room for everybody, including David
and I, since everyone else would stay in the other bedroom. But since David
had never left the United States before, he was not accustomed to normal Cuban
housing. He had perhaps seen the slums of North Philly, and probably had even
taken many pictures of negroes living in houses with plywood over all the windows.
But he had never lived in any of these houses, and it was surprisingly difficult
for him to acclimatize. Of course my wife and I had already purchased many luxuries
for this house, like the Chinese manufactured washing machine, and the Korean
manufactured television, and the VCR that we had brought over back when it was
still legal to bring VCR's into the country. We had even given Fifi the money
to buy a large fish tank and fill it with tropical fish, which is surely a measure
of solid middle class status. But David was fixated on some of the cockroaches
and the many flies. He even mentioned to me that in his opinion the house was
dirty. This was a slander against Fifi, who spent hours every day washing the
floors with a rag at the end of a stick, and scrubbing the counter tops, and
cleaning out the bathroom in the courtyard on the other side of the open patio-
about as close to indoor plumbing as you can get. I think he was unnerved by
the flies most of all, and jumped to the conclusion that flies are only found
in places that are dirty. But there was a pig living in the house next door,
in the patio next to our patio next to the bathroom, and you could see this
pig through some of the holes in the wall between our patios. Naturally garbage
was always being thrown in the patio, because the whole purpose of having a
pig was so that he could eat and get fat and produce more pork. The desire for
meat led to the pig in the patio and the garbage and the flies in an inexorable
and logical chain of events that David was unable to grasp. Perhaps in the end
he could have put up with the flies, but when I took him to the bathroom, and
showed him the tin bucket that ordinary people use to pour cold water over their
head, and also to pour into the toilet tank so that everything would run underground
until it came out somewhere, perhaps in a municipal treatment area or perhaps
in a gutter along a hilly street, I suppose he became homesick. He took many
pictures of everyone in the family, as we were clowning around, talking about
sex, or who was getting married to someone from outside the country and when
this person come to visit. Or which dollar store might have a certain type of
light bulb available, or on which corner of the city of Santiago someone would
have to wait in order to find a man who knew how to make a duplicate copy of
a certain kind of key. We continued with our normal conversations, laughing
and shouting, and David walked all around the house taking our picture from
various angles, and taking pictures of the pig from the hole in the patio wall,
and taking pictures of the bathroom, and perhaps trying to take pictures of
the flies. Remember, he did have an extensive background in sports photography
which essentially involves high speed action and careful timing. He also had
some very sophisticated photography equipment with him, so I am fairly certain
that he could indeed snap an action photo of a Cuban fly buzzing around, or
perhaps a fly being swatted by Fifi with the fly swatter we had brought over
from America, just at the very moment that the swatter and the fly collided,
capturing forever the drama of the moment and something of the personality of
this particular fly. I realize that this photo would not fit into the particular
assignment on 'The Jews of Cuba', although if Fifi had been Jewish perhaps this
photo would have been acceptable by extension. Nonetheless, photographers take
pictures for the same reason that alcoholics drink alcohol, and can invent any
kind of plausible excuse after the fact for doing what they want to do.
But after he took all these pictures, David insisted that
we go somewhere he could take a shower without any pig nearby. I tried to explain
to Fifi that some Americans are just a little bit queasy, and she was a good
sport about it all, even understanding, although with difficulty, that David
could not eat any of the dinner she had prepared, not for religious reasons,
but because he believed that he was less likely to become ill if he stuck to
bottled water and the dinner she had prepared was cooked in regular water. Well,
I smoothed everything out, since this was after all my job, and then David and
I walked up the hill to visit my friends Victor and Victoria who had a nice
bathroom with no pigs around.
Victor and Victoria were both believing Christians. In
the old days Victoria had been a nurse, and that had given her the right to
have a telephone installed in her house. This is something of a mixed blessing.
On the one hand, when you want to call somebody in Cuba, or more likely, somebody's
neighbor so they can run off and find the person you want to talk to, you don't
have to go to one of your neighbor's houses and ask to use the telephone if
you have one of your own. But on the other hand, all of your neighbors have
to come to your house if they want to call the neighbors of one of their friends.
Fortunately, Cubans are a neighborly people, and therefore the advantages for
having a phone, and all the company that comes with it, far outweighs the disadvantages
that come from what we north Americans might consider an invasion of privacy.
The waiting list for new phones, which are installed by the government for free,
is about five years long.
Victor was a math teacher at a high school about an hour
commute from his home. And since he was a very rigid Christian, he didn't believe
in stealing, not even from the government. Of course, math teachers don't have
the opportunity to steal very much anyway. Bakers can steal eggs or cooking
oil, doctors can steal the cotton that medicine is wrapped in, cigar rollers
are set for life, but math teachers can only steal chalk, which is not in very
great demand. This may have reinforced his Christian abhorrence of thievery.
Victor and Victoria had only been married for a few years, although they were
both in their forties, and many of Victoria's friends and family advised her
to get rid of this useless husband who was such a poor provider and find someone
that could contribute a couple of dollars every once in a while. It was all
very frustrating for Victor, who knew that he was completely useless, practically
speaking, since few of his students were really all that interested in quadratic
equations. Sometimes he would try to control his frustrations by talking about
the Bible, but other times his emotions would get the best of him, and one time
he left the house with a kitchen knife complaining about the squash seller in
the marketplace who had cheated him. Since he was a math teacher he had been
able to review the transaction over and over in his mind, converting kilos of
squash into Cuban pesos, and the solution to the equation was always that he
was a few kilos of calabazas short. Fortunately the squash seller was already
gone, and the neighbors reported that he had left the house furious, and Victoria
was able to remind him to think about what would Jesus do? Probably not go after
the cheats in the marketplace with a knife, from the information we have available.
We both took a shower in Victoria's house, and listened
to a few Christian Fidel jokes, and then I found David a place to stay in a
private home, because I could see that otherwise he would not be able to focus
properly on his assignment.
V
Yom Kippur morning services began early. The Synagogue,
which in the Soviet days had been converted to a storage area for one of Santiago's
carnival bands, was not exactly full, but all of the seats were taken. Jose
Almeida was the service leader, since he had taught himself and had also taught
a few generations of service leaders who had already gone on to Israel. The
entire community showed up, on time, even though no chicken would be served
until after sunset. Even a few Jews from some of the outlying towns had left
the afternoon before to assure themselves of transportation to Santiago. There
were about seventy of us in all.
Jose was a good service leader although unfortunately
he didn't know many of the special high holiday melodies. We proceeded, a little
mechanically, through every prayer in the Spanish prayer books which had been
donated from a congregation in California. There weren't enough prayer books
to go around, but there were a few for every row, so we could pass them back
and forth and keep up.
The morning service ended at about noon, and we were told
that the afternoon service would begin again at around four. But nobody went
anywhere, because there was nowhere to go. One of the Jews from Turkey bragged
about his house in Vista Allegre, and invited us to visit so he could show us
how well he was doing. Other Jews talked about the latest information from the
Jews who had gone to Israel, and the details involved in obtaining a visa. Was
it really such a good idea to leave a tropical paradise behind and start all
over again in a desert country surrounded by enemies who were already blowing
up busses and killing people in market places?
I had prepared a small study period for the period between
the morning and the afternoon services. I talked about the prophet Jonah, an
ordinary man who was too depressed to do what he had been told and who preferred
to sleep in the bottom of a boat that was about to be blown apart by a storm.
This story features the first Jewish psychiatrist, God, who at the end of the
story puts Jonah on the couch and says, "So, you're telling me that you
are really angry?" God is trying to show Jonah that depression is really
anger directed within, thereby giving guidance to all the psychiatrists who
followed. But Jonah has a difficult time admitting that he is angry, until the
very end, when God provokes his anger by creating a gourd to give him shade
and then kills the gourd. God the psychiatrist is able to illustrate his superior
understanding of the subconscious and the unconscious and the collective unconscious
with special effects unavailable to the ordinary psychiatrists. The lesson of
my analysis was that depression was normal for people who lived in frustrating
times, and that part of the significance of Yom Kippur was that we had to fight
against depression, even from the belly of a large fish, if need be. I also
talked about the story of Abraham and Isaac, which is also appropriate to the
Days of Awe. In this story God appears to take the role of a capricious dictator,
telling an old man to kill his favorite son, in order to test the old man's
loyalty. I presented the Rabbinic arguments to the effect that capricious dictators
should never be blindly obeyed, even when they speak with the voice of God.
Here again, God, in his role as the very patient teacher, working with a class
room of students who are a little disinterested and a little bit slow, has to
demonstrate by theatrical roll playing that the dictator who says 'take your
son and kill him' should not be obeyed. This little drama was staged so that
future generations of dictator worshippers would remember that the true Master
of the Universe is opposed to mindless destruction, even though it appears in
the story that He is in favor. At the very end of the story, God takes off the
greasepaint and explains very patiently, once again, that we are not really
supposed to kill our children after all. And to be fair, I did admit that this
particular interpretation is a minority report, and that the majority believe
that God should always be obeyed, even when he acts as a capricious dictator,
up until the very last moment when God changes His mind.
I concluded my sermon with a quote from Pirke Avot, the
sayings of our fathers. 'Who is a wealthy man? He who is content with what he
has. And who is a poor man? He who is not content with what he has". In
other words, there has always been suffering, and shortages of toilet paper
and cooking oil, and the best we can do is reflect on the good things that we
have, and not be forever ungrateful.
And to the cynical people who think that I was trying
to inject a discussion of Cuban politics into a Yom Kippur sermon, you should
know that I have given the same sermon in other places. Some things that seem
to be related to other things are simply coincidental.
When my part of the discussion was over, we went back
to talking about the world situation, and David went back to snapping photos.
Technically this is forbidden on Yom Kippur, but the Santiago Synagogue is fairly
liberal in some respects, or maybe they were just making an exception for my
cousin and I.
When the formal part of the service began again, Jose led us at first, through
the Torah reading and the Amidah, and then announced that the next part of the
service would be led by Adela, who had been studying Hebrew for her upcoming
move to Israel.
"This may be my last time in this Synagogue" announced Adela. 'Because
I got the final papers yesterday afternoon. I'm leaving for Havana in a few
days, and leaving for Israel as soon as I get a ticket!" And everyone offered
their congradulations, because we knew how much she wanted to go to Israel.
"So for the last time, I have the honor of being with the Jewish community,
and praying together. Ruth Adler will be taking over the pharmacy, at least
until she gets her visa! You all know how much this community has meant to me,
and how I will never forget any of you!"
It was clear that she was very emotional about having
to leave us. And then she began to pray, with us joining in, "Our God and
God of our fathers, Forgive us, Pardon us, Allow us to repent!" And after
the prayer that says, "We are thy vineyard, and thou art our Keeper, We
are thy subjects, and Thou art our King" , she began the next prayer, which
starts out in Hebrew- 'Ashamnu, Bagadnu, Gazalnu' and so forth, alphebetically
in the Hebrew alphabet, with one sin for every letter. But after the first sin,
ashamnu, which means, 'we have acted treasonably' she started to cry and stopped
the prayer in the middle! We thought that she was simply overcome, and encouraged
her to continue, but then she surprised us all by saying, through her sobs,
that she did not want to continue!
Jose assured her that we could wait for her, but Adela
then declared, cryptically, that she did not feel that she was worthy of saying
this prayer! This led to a little bit of commotion, because, why shouldn't she
be as worthy as anybody else?
"You know that I have been living in Cuba almost all of my life" She
began to explain. "And I have done everything that was necessary for me
to do. And some of the things that were necessary- well, I wish that they had
not been necessary. I was in a position where I felt I had no choice, but I
do not feel that I am able to lead the community in this prayer, because of
some of the things that I have done".
And she took off her tallit, and gave the Bimah back to Jose Almeida, and went
back to her seat, crying silently
And my cousin David, who likes to joke about everything,
said, 'What's the matter- were you a spy or something?"
And everyone became quiet, except Adela, who sobbed a
little bit more, until the President of the Synagogue reproached David, for
the first and only time, by saying, in broken English, because she didn't want
to be misunderstood through any translation, or because she wanted to speak
to David directly. "David" she said, -"there are some things
that we don't talk about. I'm sorry, but you don't live here. I'm very sorry
if I am not able to explain"
The silence that followed was uncomfortable, but then
Jose Almeida came to everyone's rescue.
"You know, what is interesting about this prayer, ashamnu, is that all
the sins are listed in the plural- We have acted treasonably, we have acted
aggressively, We have acted slanderously, and so forth. And I have been reading-
we all repeat all these sins- but can it really be that each of us is guilty
of them all? Better to say, that each of us might be ashamed of our personal
sins, and would be unable to continue. And so we read all the sins together,
supporting each other, because all of us together have been guilty of each of
these sins. We are judged as individuals, but we need the sympathy and the understanding
of everyone in order to be able to repent. And so, let us continue this prayer
together, knowing that each of has done less than we could have done. And that
this next year, may it be God's will, we can remember this moment of Yom Kippur,
as the Days of Awe come to a close, and be worthy of being written in the Book
of Life!"
He spoke exactly like a Rabbi! We were all very proud
of him. And with a little more encouragement, Adela came back to the podium,
and led us through the rest of the prayer, through her tears.
VI
The service ended at sundown, and we all joined together
for a break the fast dinner. David rushed around taking pictures again, and
Adela and everyone else were laughing, and grateful that we had lived another
year and had been maintained, almost miraculously, to this season.
The very next day David and I went back to Havana, where
we took some pictures of Jews sitting in the temporary booths of Succot surrounded
by gourds and tree branches. In Havana the roofs and walls of the Succah are
sometimes made of sugar cane. We also took some more pictures of the Rabbi from
New Orleans holding a palm branch and a citron and the willow and myrtle sprigs,
each of which is an important accessory to the celebration of this holiday.
And a day later we were back in Montreal and then Vermont.
That's how quickly people can leave one world and enter another completely different
world.
As it turned out, the New York Times never published any
of David's photos. Perhaps the story was not quite as hot as we had been led
to believe, seeing as a few TV crews had already covered it. Or perhaps a camera
is not quite capable of capturing remorse, or repentance, or any of the emotions
we feel it should be able to capture.
The trip was not a total loss for David, because he was
able to sell an article about a photographer standing in front of the capitolio
that we met on our last day in Havana. This photographer was using some type
of photographic process that went almost all the way back to Daguerre, one of
the first photographers. David sold this article to a technical photography
magazine, because nobody had known that this ancient technique was still being
utilized somewhere in the world. This article just about paid for David's travel
expenses, so he was happy to have gained the experience, and the photos. Even
the photos were not lost, because he was able to donate them to the web page
called 'The Jews of Cuba". I can refer anyone to these photos if you really
want to see them.
From what I heard, Dr Springer is still head of the Jewish
Community in Cuba. Some people, like Moses, or like Fidel himself, have so many
responsibilities that an entire lifetime is necessary to complete their appointed
work.
Luis, the old Jew who we met outside the Synagogue, died
just last year. Sadly, I have temporarily misplaced the tape of the symphony
that he had written, without ever even hearing it. It is not impossible that
this symphony is a lost masterpiece, and will be recognized as such by the entire
world, when I go through all of my old casette tapes and manage to find it.
Stranger things have happened.
Adela was able to emigrate to Israel with out any problem.
But I recently heard that a few years later, she managed to move once again,
with her aged mother, to New York! It seems that her professed love for the
State of Israel may have been a strategic tactic. Or possibly she simply changed
her mind, and preferred to spend her later years in a country that spoke English,
with lots of Spanish heard on the streets, instead of a country where the most
important languages are Hebrew, Yiddish, Arabic, and Russian. I'm sure that
we all can forgive her, to the very same extent that she was able to forgive
herself for whatever it was that caused her to cry on Yom Kippur, and to the
same exact extent that she has been able to forgive all of us for all of the
disappointments, and little treacheries, and misunderstandings, that we have
caused her to endure.